Luxury living in the heart of Lakewood Ranch.
Explore Bay Island in the Lakewood Ranch area. Browse recently sold homes, neighborhood details, and get notified the moment a new listing comes on the market.
Read More About Bay IslandYour Trusted Local Realtors
Sign Up For New Listings
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.
A buyer’s overview of the Bay Island real estate market, lifestyle, schools, and things to do — updated daily from the Stellar MLS feed.
Bay Island has no active MLS listings right now. New homes are added throughout the day as agents enter them into Stellar MLS. Set up a saved search to be notified the moment a home in Bay Island hits the market.
Looking to compare home types? Browse single-family homes, villas, or townhomes across Bay Island and the surrounding area.
Homes in Bay Island typically offer a range of floor plans. Inventory spans maintenance-free villas, family-friendly single-family homes, and luxury estates from national and regional builders such as Taylor Morrison, Neal Communities, and Pulte Homes.
Use the full property search to filter by price, beds, lot size, pool, and gated access.
Bay Island sits within the master-planned Lakewood Ranch corridor on Florida’s Gulf Coast — routinely ranked the #1 top-selling multigenerational community in the U.S. Residents enjoy championship golf, Waterside Place, Main Street shopping and dining, miles of trails, and a short drive to downtown Sarasota’s arts district and the white-sand beaches of Anna Maria Island and Siesta Key.
Homes in Bay Island are zoned to either the School District of Manatee County or Sarasota County Schools, depending on the parcel. Independent ratings, attendance boundaries, and test scores are published by GreatSchools. Always verify the assigned school for a specific address before making an offer.